How to Approach Star Trek Limited

This past weekend was the Magic World Championship. It's the first tournament we get to see Star Trek cards on display, and we also get a look into Star Trek Limited.
I've had several Worlds players ask me for advice on Star Trek Limited prior to the event. The window was very short between the set's release and the tournament itself, which left some players in a position where they needed to shortcut one of the two formats, and for most teams, that's always going to be Limited since it's usually a more autonomous process.
While I didn't have all the answers, and still don't, I have a good feel for how I want to approach the set for now.
Star Trek is a highly synergistic format where the cards play off of each other, and even a lot of the good rares require some amount of synergy to maximize. This isn't Reality Fracture anymore, a format I found to be basically absent of synergy and just focused on value.
It's hard to escape trying to focus on a synergy in this set, but the way I've been approaching it is by finding a lane and then branching out.
Let me explain.
I went into the format wanting to force Strange New World payoffs, which was an extremely successful approach for the first handful of drafts. I may have been blinded by how easy it was to get the good payoffs late, but then word got out and that stopped happening. Alternatively, it could have just been short term variance, who's to say?
When it stopped working I quickly adjusted my thought process to "Maybe I should just draft the decks they want me to." Basically, let's just go back to drafting decks like Borgs, Klingons, Spacecraft, and Dilemmas.
While I started that way I was still getting the payoffs later in some of the drafts. I decided to just take the more logical approach of starting in a specific lane, and branching that out into Strange New World, which is what I figured would work before the set came out. However, at the beginning people were drafting very "safely" and letting value fly around the table far too late. An example would be me opening Pah-Wraith pack-one pick-one in three of my first four drafts, not taking it two of the times, and both times it wheeled. Now I know to take it aggressively because the format allows you the time to cast it and set it up.
Regardless, the format is kind of messy. I still couldn't tell you what the best archetype is because they all kind of blend together into soup style decks for the most part. In some cases you can get a lot of uncommon payoffs and really do the things they want you to, but it's the exception. For instance, Izzet Spells is awesome if you get enough of the uncommon payoffs, and BW Borgs is fantastic when you get a couple Locutus, the One Who Speaks with a deck full of artifact creatures.
I think the set does a really good job at forcing you to read signals and find your lane. It also forces you to not ignore the lands in packs because additional payoffs could be right around the corner for taking them. Due to how important lands are, there's a lot of tension on every pick. Do I take this land I may not play at all, or this filler dilemma card I may get three of and only play one?
Every pick up until the last two or three of a pack is immensely critical.
I also don't think I've ever struggled as much to get removal in a format. A lot of my losses come down to me stumbling on land drops after my fourth land, and then my opponent just casting a couple of land cyclers and the one I can't answer just runs me over. I'm still tweaking my personal algorithm of pick orders.

This draft I started with All Good Things (the Simic Saga), but quickly pivoted to Golgari and stayed in that lane while picking up lands I got for "free" out of packs where there was only filler leftover. I intended to not play The Wrath of Khan, but since I have almost no removal I was forced to include it to break through any kind of meaningful ground stall. Moopsies and such would cause great headaches because of my inability to interact with creatres, and no Pavel to deck the opponent in a battlefield stalemate.
I end up picking up a couple of Strange New World payoffs and playing them, but it's not my entire focus. This deck would have loved a copy of Stray from History, which is a card I've been liking as a one-of more and more.

For this draft I, again, stayed in my lane. I waited for splashes and picked up a couple of He's Dead, Jims. I set myself up to be able to take and play any removal pieces, and I managed to snag a couple while mostly focusing on green cards.
I wanted to try Vulcan Mind-Meld, and I do believe it has a niche place to be played, but this wasn't it. I think it's a card that has potential when you have enough bounce spells to mitigate the "downside" of the it of giving them a card. If you give them a creature and they spent their turn casting it only for you to bounce it, then it's still a massive swing in tempo and card advantage. Otherwise, I'd avoid the card because it's got too many uncontrollable variables.
Will the cards in their deck advance my plan? Will I give them a much needed land drop? Will they hit my busted rare? A lot of variance to the card that makes me want to avoid it.
Anyways, this deck was fantastic and the epitome of how I want to approach the format at the moment.

This was an extremely cool deck. Sometimes it functioned as an aggressive Gruul Landfall style deck, and in other games it acted as a complete control deck that used its rares as finishers. I was only able to cast Infinite Diversity once, but in multiple games I was just pulling ahead with my normal cards while setting up Diversity, and the opponents couldn't beat my initial curve out making it unnecessary to cast. Had my opponents put up a better fight it would have outright won me most of those games.
I again focued on just two colors for this deck, then adding splashes that were low cost. While I have virtually no Strange New World payoffs, I'm still splashing other colors because the format allows for it and supports it well. In this case, it's just a single removal spell.
I want to always have Stange New World in the back of my mind as a possibility, but I think if you're not first-picking one of the better payoffs you should be willing to abandon the idea unless it comes to you. Each and every playable has mattered, and I've regretted a lot of my less safe picks this set.
So, I'm going to start trying to draft the set a lot more conservatively and dialing it back a bit and let the cards come to me rather than forcing the issue.
I've heard a lot of criticism of this set, mostly from names and faces I don't recognize, and I think a lot of it is a knee-jerk reaction of wanting to dislike UB sets. I admit, the set looks pretty tacky to me, but I think the set itself is a fantastic Limited experience and one of (if not the) best Limited set of the year.





Comments